Who is Extinction Rebellion? (An open question)

It is disappointing to me that I feel compelled to write this. Perhaps I’m just a cynic and a sceptic.

I really wanted to believe in Extinction Rebellion, and when I first learnt of this project was pleased to learn that there were people who wanted to discuss, in an open way, human extinction as part of this mass extinction event we are living through. Last summer various members of XR contacted me, asking if I wanted to get involved. I cautiously offered to help them edit their pieces for media outlets, but stepped away after seeing how bureaucratically organisational the project was at the time (I can only guess as to its current internal structure, based on what I know from friends involved in the project).

I’ve enjoyed a great deal of what XR has done and cannot deny that the project has done something impressive.

However I have sincere questions and concerns, which I will state openly here, for anyone involved in XR to disregard or respond to.

Environmentalism has had a clear internal conflict, as a movement and an ideology, between what is often referred to as the dark and the bright wings. I often split this as the dark environmentalists and the bright greens. The poet and ecologist Gary Snyder has characterised this split as the Break Throughs (more technology to solve global warming and energy crisis, to keep this culture going as usual) and those interested in Biodiversity (non-anthropocentric concern for life in a broad sense).

My question to XR is, which are you? Do you want to keep the industrial-agri-machine going, or are you concerned with life living in earth, under this sky? Are you advocating sustainable violation of this planet, or ending the violation (or attempting to end) the violation of earth?

This is probably my main question to XR, but it is not the only.

It is obvious that, right now, revolutions sell. Media outlets, films, recording artists, etc,. The image of uprising, the meme of popularist victory, is in fashion.

My question is why is this (and XR) fitting into the capitalist-consumerist production-narrative so easily?

My feeling is because there is no actual structural (or deconstructural) challenge being made by this fashionable “rebellion”, it is readily embraced and actively sold.

My final point is less of a question and more of a challenge.

I don’t know about you, but I’m fucking sick of protests, appealing to authorities who obviously don’t give a shit, and keeping power in the hands of abusers. Why is XR retaining the same power dynamics that has got us here? Politicians and business leaders will prioritise industry over ecological-welfare every time – no matter how self destructive this is. So why are you protestating to them and not directly dismantling and destroying the machine that is causing this extinction event? Why are you apologising for blocking bridges, and not sabotaging fracking equipment, and refusing to apologise for doing so? Why are you chanting on the streets, and not defending the wildlife that this culture violates?

I guess my question to Extinction Rebellion ultimately comes down to, who are you, and do you even know?

Again, perhaps I am a cynic and a sceptic (well, I am but that is besides the point), but I can’t help but worry that XR’s greatest achievement might well be becoming a greater disappointment than Occupy. I hope you can prove me wrong.

7 thoughts on “Who is Extinction Rebellion? (An open question)

Add yours

  1. First, try not to have everyone die, by whatever means. If that means working with the system and not by entirely dismantling it, so be it. Then work on making everything else better. This isn’t an either/or. A question of priorities. Everyone living a green, vegan, environmentally friendly life would be ideal but it’s not a realistic short-term goal while in the shadow of an existential threat.


  2. I have the following on copy and paste whenever and where ever I come across an XR related post. A million new homesteading homes on our dying land, such as moorland, with homeowners, family units and new communities dedicated to permaculture, reforestation and growing food in a way that (1) increases species diversity (2) rejuvenates the soil (3) generates carbon sinks and geo engineers and (4) creates a new way of life whilst (5) putting in place a decentralised food growing network more resilient to the projected weather extremes and (7) giving people a stake in the future given what they have to give up thus creating a new social class of ‘bio geo engineers’.


  3. Thank you for this Julian, I agree 100%.

    Nothing can change while this death cult of a culture exists & the system will let you do anything only if it is not a threat to it.

    Always enjoy reading your work.


  4. Just what this recent hysteria around XR needs, more critical thinking words such as your own need to be spoken out against this blatant recuperation of peoples genuine concern (misplaced theoretically and tactically in my opinion) about the destruction of the planet we live on. Wonder if you have seen this recent piece by winter oak/acorn (https://winteroak.org.uk/2019/04/23/rebellion-extinction-a-capitalist-scam-to-hijack-our-resistance/) about the financial backers of XR and also the short lived ‘business site’ which reinforces the green capitalist element of the so called ‘movement.’ Their links to Unilever a well known deforester and animal tester says it all. This all a trend in the last couple of decades where we see more and more movements arising that prey on peoples genuine feeling of unease with how the world is being run but is just being funneled into recuperative actions that are just a readjusting of the systems that control us, captalism, the state, society, civilisation reforming itself to counter the ground swell. What is more worrying is the re-emergence of doctrinaire non-violence, where any other tactic that is anywhere near a threat to authority is silenced, such examples as the anti-globalisation movement, anti-war etc. Some these XR’s need to read Gelederloo’s ‘How Non-Violence Protects The State.’

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: